External provider setting exception #8921

0

464199480 created 12 days ago

Why is it necessary to encrypt the Client secret? This leads to a very serious disaster in the update of the Release environment, and this is not mentioned in the migration instructions.

0

EngincanV created 12 days ago

Support Team .NET Developer

Hi, the encryption of the Client Secret in ABP’s External Provider settings is a security measure designed to protect sensitive authentication credentials. Storing client secrets in plaintext poses a significant security risk, especially if unauthorized users gain access to the database or configuration files. Encrypting them helps prevent exposure in case of data leaks or misconfiguration.

Regards.

0

464199480 created 12 days ago

Ok.
How to solve the problem of failed login from External provider now? The Client secrets obtained by my provider are encrypted.

0

EngincanV created 12 days ago

Support Team .NET Developer

Ok.
How to solve the problem of failed login from External provider now? The Client secrets obtained by my provider are encrypted.

Hi, since the client secret is encrypted then the provider is also expecting it from you with the encrypted value, so you can just set the clientSecret according to the provided value:

context.Services.AddAuthentication()
            .AddMicrosoftAccount(MicrosoftAccountDefaults.AuthenticationScheme, options =>
            {
                //other configs...
                
                options.ClientSecret = "<set-your-client-secret>"; //get it from appsettings.json or secret manager
            })

0

464199480 created 12 days ago

Using your approach will result in the clientSecret configured by tenant in the setting being ineffective.

0

liangshiwei created 9 days ago

Support Team Fullstack Developer

Open
External provider setting exception

What is the error message, could you share the full logs?

0

liangshiwei created 9 days ago

Support Team Fullstack Developer

Hi,

We will fix the problem in the next patch version. and your ticket was refunded.

you can try this as a temporary solution

[Dependency(ReplaceServices = true)]
[ExposeServices(typeof(ExternalProviderSettingsHelper))]
public class MyExternalProviderSettingsHelper : ExternalProviderSettingsHelper
{
    private readonly ISettingDefinitionManager _settingDefinitionManager;
    private readonly ISettingEncryptionService _settingEncryptionService;
    private readonly ICurrentTenant _currentTenant;
    private readonly AbpExternalProviderOptions _externalProviderOptions;
    private readonly ISettingManager _settingManager;
    private readonly IJsonSerializer _jsonSerializer;
    public MyExternalProviderSettingsHelper(
        ICurrentTenant currentTenant, 
        IOptions<AbpExternalProviderOptions> externalProvidersOptions,
        ISettingManager settingManager,
        IJsonSerializer jsonSerializer,
        IStringEncryptionService stringEncryptionService,
        ISettingDefinitionManager settingDefinitionManager,
        ISettingEncryptionService settingEncryptionService) 
           : base(currentTenant, externalProvidersOptions, settingManager, jsonSerializer, stringEncryptionService)
    {
        _settingDefinitionManager = settingDefinitionManager;
        _settingEncryptionService = settingEncryptionService;
        _currentTenant = currentTenant;
        _externalProviderOptions = externalProvidersOptions.Value;
        _settingManager = settingManager;
        _jsonSerializer = jsonSerializer;
    }

    public override async Task<List<ExternalProviderSettings>> GetAllAsync()
    {
        var allSettings = new List<ExternalProviderSettings>();

        List<ExternalProviderSettings> hostSettingsList;
        using (_currentTenant.Change(null))
        {
            hostSettingsList = await GetSettingsListOrNullAsync(GlobalSettingValueProvider.ProviderName, null);
        }

        var settingsList = _currentTenant.IsAvailable
            ? await GetSettingsListOrNullAsync(TenantSettingValueProvider.ProviderName, _currentTenant.Id?.ToString())
            : hostSettingsList;

        foreach (var externalProviderDefinition in _externalProviderOptions.Definitions)
        {
            var newSettings = CreateSettings(externalProviderDefinition);
            var existSettings = settingsList?.FirstOrDefault(x => x.Name == externalProviderDefinition.Name);
            if (existSettings != null)
            {
                CloneSettings(existSettings, newSettings);
            }

            if (_currentTenant.IsAvailable)
            {
                newSettings.Enabled = hostSettingsList?.FirstOrDefault(x => x.Name == externalProviderDefinition.Name)?.Enabled
                                      ?? false;
            }

            allSettings.Add(newSettings);
        }

        var settingDefinition = await _settingDefinitionManager.GetAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders);
        foreach (var secretProperty in allSettings.SelectMany(setting => setting.SecretProperties))
        {
            secretProperty.Value = _settingEncryptionService.Decrypt(settingDefinition, secretProperty.Value);
        }

        return allSettings;
    }

    public async override Task SetAsync(ExternalProviderSettings settings)
    {
        var definition = _externalProviderOptions.Definitions.FirstOrDefault(x => x.Name == settings.Name);
        if (definition == null)
        {
            throw new Exception($"External provider with {settings.Name} not definition!");
        }

        var newSettings = CreateSettings(definition);

        CloneSettings(settings, newSettings);

        if (_currentTenant.IsAvailable)
        {
            newSettings.Enabled = true;
        }

        var existSettingsList = (_currentTenant.IsAvailable
            ? await GetSettingsListOrNullAsync(TenantSettingValueProvider.ProviderName, _currentTenant.Id?.ToString())
            : await GetSettingsListOrNullAsync(GlobalSettingValueProvider.ProviderName, null)) ?? new List<ExternalProviderSettings>();

        existSettingsList.RemoveAll(x => x.Name == definition.Name);
        existSettingsList.Add(newSettings);
        
        var settingDefinition = await _settingDefinitionManager.GetAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders);
        foreach (var secretProperty in newSettings.SecretProperties)
        {
            secretProperty.Value = _settingEncryptionService.Encrypt(settingDefinition, secretProperty.Value);
        }

        if (_currentTenant.IsAvailable)
        {
            await _settingManager.SetForCurrentTenantAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders, _jsonSerializer.Serialize(existSettingsList));
        }
        else
        {
            await _settingManager.SetGlobalAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders, _jsonSerializer.Serialize(existSettingsList));
        }
    }
}

0

464199480 created 8 days ago

Hi !
I applied this piece of code, but the issue still remained unsolved.

Could you copy the code of Microsoft.AspNetCore.Authentication.MicrosoftAccount?
The ClientSecret obtained in the code is encrypted content.

[Dependency(ReplaceServices = true)]
[ExposeServices(typeof(ExternalProviderSettingsHelper))]
public class MyExternalProviderSettingsHelper : ExternalProviderSettingsHelper
{
private readonly ISettingDefinitionManager _settingDefinitionManager;
private readonly ISettingEncryptionService _settingEncryptionService;
private readonly ICurrentTenant _currentTenant;
private readonly AbpExternalProviderOptions _externalProviderOptions;
private readonly ISettingManager _settingManager;
private readonly IJsonSerializer _jsonSerializer;
public MyExternalProviderSettingsHelper(
ICurrentTenant currentTenant,
IOptions<AbpExternalProviderOptions> externalProvidersOptions,
ISettingManager settingManager,
IJsonSerializer jsonSerializer,
IStringEncryptionService stringEncryptionService,
ISettingDefinitionManager settingDefinitionManager,
ISettingEncryptionService settingEncryptionService)
: base(currentTenant, externalProvidersOptions, settingManager, jsonSerializer, stringEncryptionService)
{
_settingDefinitionManager = settingDefinitionManager;
_settingEncryptionService = settingEncryptionService;
_currentTenant = currentTenant;
_externalProviderOptions = externalProvidersOptions.Value;
_settingManager = settingManager;
_jsonSerializer = jsonSerializer;
}

0

liangshiwei created 8 days ago

Support Team Fullstack Developer

Hi

What is the error message, could you share the full logs? thanks

0

464199480 created 8 days ago

Hi

AuthenticationFailureException: OAuth token endpoint failure: invalid_client;Description=AADSTS7000215: Invalid client secret provided. Ensure the secret being sent in the request is the client secret value, not the client secret ID, for a secret added to app 'e42cec2e-afd5-45ef-83e6-85bb54f58b19'. Trace ID: 0262dabf-2e50-47a0-8117-7d83235a2100 Correlation ID: f7fce4f7-bef4-44b9-917e-b5077b8d7bc8 Timestamp: 2025-03-11 06:05:36Z;Uri=https://login.microsoftonline.com/error?code=7000215

0

464199480 created 8 days ago

Could you try to apply for a Microsoft clientId? It might help to reproduce my problem.

0

liangshiwei created 8 days ago

Support Team Fullstack Developer

Hi,

I can reproduce the problem.

Try this

[Dependency(ReplaceServices = true)]
[ExposeServices(typeof(ExternalProviderSettingsHelper))]
public class MyExternalProviderSettingsHelper : ExternalProviderSettingsHelper
{
    private readonly ISettingDefinitionManager _settingDefinitionManager;
    private readonly ISettingEncryptionService _settingEncryptionService;
    private readonly ICurrentTenant _currentTenant;
    private readonly AbpExternalProviderOptions _externalProviderOptions;
    private readonly ISettingManager _settingManager;
    private readonly IJsonSerializer _jsonSerializer;
    public MyExternalProviderSettingsHelper(
        ICurrentTenant currentTenant, 
        IOptions<AbpExternalProviderOptions> externalProvidersOptions,
        ISettingManager settingManager,
        IJsonSerializer jsonSerializer,
        IStringEncryptionService stringEncryptionService,
        ISettingDefinitionManager settingDefinitionManager,
        ISettingEncryptionService settingEncryptionService) 
           : base(currentTenant, externalProvidersOptions, settingManager, jsonSerializer, stringEncryptionService)
    {
        _settingDefinitionManager = settingDefinitionManager;
        _settingEncryptionService = settingEncryptionService;
        _currentTenant = currentTenant;
        _externalProviderOptions = externalProvidersOptions.Value;
        _settingManager = settingManager;
        _jsonSerializer = jsonSerializer;
    }

    protected override async Task<ExternalProviderSettings> GetSettingsAsync(ExternalProviderDefinition definition, string providerName, string providerKey)
    {
        var settings = await base.GetSettingsAsync(definition, providerName, providerKey);

         var settingDefinition = await _settingDefinitionManager.GetAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders);
        foreach (var secretProperty in settings.SecretProperties)
        {
            secretProperty.Value = _settingEncryptionService.Decrypt(settingDefinition, secretProperty.Value);
        }

        return settings;
    }

    public override async Task<List<ExternalProviderSettings>> GetAllAsync()
    {
        var allSettings = new List<ExternalProviderSettings>();

        List<ExternalProviderSettings> hostSettingsList;
        using (_currentTenant.Change(null))
        {
            hostSettingsList = await GetSettingsListOrNullAsync(GlobalSettingValueProvider.ProviderName, null);
        }

        var settingsList = _currentTenant.IsAvailable
            ? await GetSettingsListOrNullAsync(TenantSettingValueProvider.ProviderName, _currentTenant.Id?.ToString())
            : hostSettingsList;

        foreach (var externalProviderDefinition in _externalProviderOptions.Definitions)
        {
            var newSettings = CreateSettings(externalProviderDefinition);
            var existSettings = settingsList?.FirstOrDefault(x => x.Name == externalProviderDefinition.Name);
            if (existSettings != null)
            {
                CloneSettings(existSettings, newSettings);
            }

            if (_currentTenant.IsAvailable)
            {
                newSettings.Enabled = hostSettingsList?.FirstOrDefault(x => x.Name == externalProviderDefinition.Name)?.Enabled
                                      ?? false;
            }

            allSettings.Add(newSettings);
        }

        var settingDefinition = await _settingDefinitionManager.GetAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders);
        foreach (var secretProperty in allSettings.SelectMany(setting => setting.SecretProperties))
        {
            secretProperty.Value = _settingEncryptionService.Decrypt(settingDefinition, secretProperty.Value);
        }

        return allSettings;
    }

    public async override Task SetAsync(ExternalProviderSettings settings)
    {
        var definition = _externalProviderOptions.Definitions.FirstOrDefault(x => x.Name == settings.Name);
        if (definition == null)
        {
            throw new Exception($"External provider with {settings.Name} not definition!");
        }

        var newSettings = CreateSettings(definition);

        CloneSettings(settings, newSettings);

        if (_currentTenant.IsAvailable)
        {
            newSettings.Enabled = true;
        }

        var existSettingsList = (_currentTenant.IsAvailable
            ? await GetSettingsListOrNullAsync(TenantSettingValueProvider.ProviderName, _currentTenant.Id?.ToString())
            : await GetSettingsListOrNullAsync(GlobalSettingValueProvider.ProviderName, null)) ?? new List<ExternalProviderSettings>();

        existSettingsList.RemoveAll(x => x.Name == definition.Name);
        existSettingsList.Add(newSettings);
        
        var settingDefinition = await _settingDefinitionManager.GetAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders);
        foreach (var secretProperty in newSettings.SecretProperties)
        {
            secretProperty.Value = _settingEncryptionService.Encrypt(settingDefinition, secretProperty.Value);
        }

        if (_currentTenant.IsAvailable)
        {
            await _settingManager.SetForCurrentTenantAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders, _jsonSerializer.Serialize(existSettingsList));
        }
        else
        {
            await _settingManager.SetGlobalAsync(AccountSettingNames.ExternalProviders, _jsonSerializer.Serialize(existSettingsList));
        }
    }
}

0

464199480 created 6 days ago

Hi.
It works.
When will the fix be released?

0

liangshiwei created 6 days ago

Support Team Fullstack Developer

Hi,

We may release a patch version next week

0

maliming created about 19 hours ago

Support Team Fullstack Developer

hi 464199480

Remember to remove the MyExternalProviderSettingsHelper in the next patch version.

0

alex.maiereanu@3sstudio.com created about 19 hours ago

Hi, is this also fixing the issue that on migration to 9.1 the old values are not usable anymore? Or we need to reconfigure them?

I understand that this is a security measure but this should have been part of the migration guide so that we know what we are signing up to :D

0

maliming created about 19 hours ago

Support Team Fullstack Developer

hi alex.maiereanu@3sstudio.com

Yes, the next patch version will fix all.

17 Answer(s)

ABP Live Training
Packages

Do you need assistance from an ABP expert?

Mastering
ABP Framework

External provider setting exception #8921

17 Answer(s)

ABP Live TrainingPackages

Do you need assistance from an ABP expert?

MasteringABP Framework

ABP Live Training
Packages

Mastering
ABP Framework