Activities of "okains"
Check the docs before asking a question: https://docs.abp.io/en/commercial/latest/ Check the samples, to see the basic tasks: https://docs.abp.io/en/commercial/latest/samples/index The exact solution to your question may have been answered before, please use the search on the homepage.
- ABP Framework version: v4.0.1
- UI type: MVC
- DB provider: EF Core
- Tiered (MVC) or Identity Server Seperated (Angular): no
- Exception message and stack trace:
- Steps to reproduce the issue:
<br> <br> My last question, regarding the Payment module, could have been avoided if you had proper documentation, including expected use-cases with sample code. I am now planning on implementing the Blog Module and there is no documentation at all, just a TODO. So what to do? Well, I searched support and found another question about Blogs, posted recently, that included the fact that the blogs were at /blogs/{NAME} . Ah, great, now I can go that page, create a new post, but I get the JS error below.
This is the only complaint that I have with ABP: The module documentation doesn't go far enough in depth. Not even close. Going back to the Payment module question that I posted previously, there were so many follow ups that I had to ask, and even then your architecture for that Module was not fully explained, so I gave up (until now!).
I know you are amazing developers and software architects. That is why I paid for the commercial license, because your code is great and you obviously know what you are doing. I have both managed and been a part of high end development teams, and I understand that we all would rather spend time working on new code than documenting what is there already, as of course it is 'easy to understand and makes sense' (because you / we wrote it!).
However the X amount of hours it might take your lead module developer to fully document a module, versus the 8000 total hours that it might save your customers should be a priority. We pay for the commercial license because we can see a list of all these amazing features. When we get to the point of implementation, check the docs and see a page of incomplete documentation, or worse, a TODO, and realise that now we need to invest hours / days of our time investigating your libraries and asking questions like this on your premium support then it makes us question the value of our purchase.
Also, we have a certain number of premium support tickets available per year. These should be used to ask proper questions when we have significant issues where there is a bug / blocker type situation. Having to spend our premium support tickets on basic questions that should be covered in documentation both frustrates you and us.
The rest of your documentation is quite good, especially the Web Application Development Tutorials. I would ask that you provide the same level of documentation for your Modules as soon as possible.
Thanks,
Karim
OK, after spending some time reviewing your answer and digging into the namespaces around Payment I am starting to better understand how this module works. I can now inject the service, and I can see how the Gateway Page works and I can see the rest of the payment infrastructure.
I think fundamentally though that the documentation is not great, and it has taken more time than it should for me to get up to speed with how this works. I suggest that you provide in depth documentation for the Payment module, and probably for all modules, so that us, as your customers, can spend less time figuring out your infrastructure and more time on our projects.
I have 2 more questions around this then we can close out. First of all, the 2Checkout documentation lists a certain set of params in the json configuration. I have supplied all of these, yet I still get an error:
' ArgumentException: Two checkout extra parameters are not configured for this product !' error.
Here is my JSON config for payment, the 'XXXXXXXX--MYSIGHERE--XXXXXXXX' param is replace with a valid 2Checkout signature.
*
"Payment": {
"Payu": {
"Merchant": "TEST",
"Signature": "SECRETKEY",
"LanguageCode": "en",
"CurrencyCode": "USD",
"VatRate": "0",
"PriceType": "GROSS",
"Shipping": "0",
"Installment": "1",
"TestOrder": "1",
"Debug": "1"
},
"TwoCheckout": {
"Signature": "XXXXXXXX--MYSIGHERE--XXXXXXXX",
"CheckoutUrl": "https://secure.2checkout.com/order/checkout.php",
"LanguageCode": "en",
"CurrencyCode": "USD",
"TestOrder": "1"
},
"PayPal": {
"ClientId": "CLIENTID",
"Secret": "SECRET",
"CurrencyCode": "USD",
"Environment": "Sandbox",
"Locale": "enUS"
},
"Stripe": {
"PublishableKey": "PUBLISHABLEKEY",
"SecretKey": "SECRET_KEY",
"PaymentMethodTypes": [ "alipay" ]
}
}*
Second, I will be using a 3rd party gateway and I would like to know how to set this up correctly. There is no documentation that describes how to do this. In your documentation you state the following:
PaymentOptions is used to store list of payment gateways. You don't have to configure this manually for existing payment gateways. You can, however, add a new gateway like below:
Configure<PaymentOptions>(options => { options.Gateways.Add( new PaymentGatewayConfiguration( "MyPaymentGatewayName", new FixedLocalizableString("MyPaymentGatewayName"), typeof(MyPaymentGateway) ) ); });
What is MyPaymentGateway? Can you provide an example of this, along with any supporting classes or DTOs that I would need to configure a new payment gateway? I am sure that I am not the only person having trouble with this, I suggest updating your documentation to cover these common use cases and provide us, the end user, with functional examples of how to get things done.
Thanks for your help,
Karim
I don't understand. In the documentation it clearly states that there is a PaymentRequest object, also a PaymentRequestAppService, and a PaymentRequestRepository. None of these are created when I install the module. As you can see from the screenshot below the only thing related to 'PaymentRequest' are the migrations, which work fine. Other than that there is nothing, no Payment Gateway Selection UI, no admin menu options, nothing.
So what I am saying is that these required files are not being created on add-module. I understand about configuring the payment gateways in appsettings.json, that is fine. But what about all of the supporting files and UI?
Can you let me know if this is a bug, or if there are other steps that I need to take?
<br>
<br>
<br>
Check the docs before asking a question: https://docs.abp.io/en/commercial/latest/ Check the samples, to see the basic tasks: https://docs.abp.io/en/commercial/latest/samples/index The exact solution to your question may have been answered before, please use the search on the homepage.
- ABP Framework version: v4.0.0
- UI type: MVC
- Tiered (MVC) or Identity Server Seperated (Angular): no
- Exception message and stack trace:
- Steps to reproduce the issue:
I have tried adding the Payment Module into 2 separate 4.0.0 projects, in one case using SUITE and in another using the CLI. In both cases all package references & DB Migration code is created, however there is nothing else created. No domain classes, services, UI, or anything else is there.
The 2nd project was a brand new, clean install with no other modules added. I used the CLI to add the module, it shows as INSTALLED when I browse to the modules section in SUITE. But still, nothing has been installed / added other than the packages and dbmigrations.
Please let me know if this is a bug, or am I missing a step.
Thanks,
Karim